The Training
It began in 1977 with a trial advocacy class taught at the University of Miami School of Law. The professor was Roy Black. The course, and Jerry's admiration for Roy, changed his life.
Black had recently left the Public Defender’s Office and opened an unassuming downtown practice with Jack Denaro. Jerry asked Black, repeatedly, for a chance to help on a case, and after many rejections got one: Roy handed him a tape recorder and sent him to Liberty City to interview witnesses in a murder case. It was a revelation — the discipline, tactics, strategy and preparation he saw there. Black impressed on him that becoming a trial lawyer required commitment and experience earned one case at a time. At Black’s recommendation Jerry began volunteering at the Miami-Dade Public Defender’s Office and entered its certified legal intern program. As a certified intern he tried six jury trials before law school ended – all acquittals. His first jury trial was an escape prosecution in August 1977 where the jury returned a not-guilty verdict after 13 minutes of deliberation.1 When he told Roy, he did not get the pat on the back he hoped for, his comment drove home the level of commitment that it would take to achieve his goal:
“You can consider yourself a trial attorney
when you have tried 100 jury trials.”
Roy Black to Jerry Breslin 1977.
1 That first trial is the perfect example of theory, strategy and tactics. The prosecutor had to prove simply that the Defendant was in prison, and was then out of prison without permission. Which is exactly what he told the jury. The State had no response to the testimony and evidence that the accused fled prison to defend himself from the brutal daily assaults. The jury quickly found him not guilty and it was reported in the media. Jim Malone, “Man Cleared In Escape Back To Jail,” The Miami Herald, Aug. 19, 1977, at 37 (identifying Jerrell Breslin as the Public Defender’s Office legal intern who handled the case); alternate ed., “Jury Believed Him, But He’s Taken Back to Jail,” at 154 (reporting the 13-minute jury deliberation and quoting Assistant State Attorney Harry Solomon described the defense as “beautiful.”).
Main edition;
alternate edition.
Experience
After his internship, Jerry Breslin began practicing law at the Miami-Dade Public Defender’s Office in 1978, trying felony cases in a courthouse where, like the public defenders before him, trials occurred every week and often two a week. He passed his hundredth jury trial after leaving the office, before he was thirty-five. In the past ten years, he has focused on complex commercial disputes, fraud, real estate and finance litigation, professional liability, and the appeals that follow. He has appeared in the Florida state courts, the United States District Courts for the Southern, Middle, and Northern Districts of Florida, the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Florida, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. He is a member of The Florida Bar’s Business Law and Trial Lawyers sections. He is seventy-three and is not building a book of business. He does not have to work; he loves his work.2
2 Stan Sinberg, “Basic Black,” Florida Super Lawyers 2007 - South Florida, at 12 (discussing Black’s 1971-1976 public defender service and the 1976 opening of his downtown Miami practice with Jack Denaro).
Source
The Practice
Lawyers cannot try cases alone. It is a team effort. Serious litigation is never a one-lawyer exercise. It requires a coordinated team: the lawyers who know the client and the record, trial counsel who can shape and present the case, and—when needed—the right experts, consultants, local counsel, and technology professionals.
Jerry serves as litigation counsel in matters where the consequence of getting it wrong is too great to treat trial preparation as a way to increase billing. He works with existing counsel, not around them. The lawyers who understand the business, documents, witnesses, and history of the dispute remain essential. Jerry directs the trial strategy and prepares the case for the moment when decision-makers must be persuaded.
Strategy
A trial is not won when opening statements begin. It is won through early choices: which facts will carry the case, which themes a jury can trust, which witnesses must be prepared, which documents must be made understandable, and which arguments should never be made at all. What must be proved, and what evidence proves it? What will the decision-maker actually understand and remember? What does the other side need in order to win, and how do we prevent it? Does this step advance a credible path to strengthen the case for trial?
Reality is that most cases settle. The settlement any client wants is the one where the opposition knows that a trial will only make the situation worse.
The right team for the right matter
Not every serious matter requires Jerry to try it. Some require a different lawyer, a different team, a different firm, or an entirely different strategy. The most valuable time in any case—by far—is spent mapping the theory of prosecution of your claims or the theory of defense to theirs.
Clients and lawyers bring Jerry matters at the beginning, when the choices are still open: what the case is really about, what it is worth, what it will cost to win, whether it should be fought at all, and who should fight it. He has spent four decades watching which lawyers, experts, and strategies win before Florida judges and juries. When the right answer is someone else, he says so, helps assemble the team—trial counsel, subject-matter counsel, local counsel, experts—and either stays on to help or steps away.
The matters where this makes a difference tend to be those in which the stakes are large enough that a wrong first decision is expensive. Those are the conversations Jerry takes.